July 26, 2021

Data Catalyst Institute Analysis of NYC Council Int. 2311

By Data Catalyst Institute

The Data Catalyst Institute (DCI) works to support stakeholders and policymakers as they undertake the important and difficult work of enacting sound, operational public policy governing the use of data by and for consumers and data-focused enterprises. To celebrate good policy and identify challenges of many proposals, DCI considers and reports on regulatory and legislative proposals.

NYC Council Int. 2311 (“Data on orders placed through third-party food delivery services”) is rooted in good intention, and may have an operational foundation that could benefit consumers and restaurants eventually, but in its current form it hurts everyone and does catastrophic harm to the progress made in recent years to reduce unwanted data sharing and increase data security.

Secondary data markets always pose risks. A forced secondary data market would do untold harm to millions of New Yorkers, thousands of New York restaurants, and ultimately create a precedent for violating privacy policies and contracts that are, in lieu of a national privacy law, the best way to maintain privacy obligations and security requirements.

The Data Catalyst Institute strongly recommends the New York City Council reconsider Int. 2311, and, at a minimum, address the privacy and independent restaurant liability implications before moving forward.

Further analysis can be found here.

More Insights

Discover, Buy, and Sell Fine Art: Q&A with Artsy’s VP of Collector Sales, Jessica Backus

Check out how Artsy - an online marketplace where people can buy and sell art - has taken an age-old practice to e-commerce in our Q&A with their VP of Collector Sales, Jessica Backus.

By Data Catalyst Institute

Reports of My Death Are Greatly Exaggerated: New Research Shows That Small Businesses Still Thrive With Brick-and-Mortar Sales

While more and more small businesses adopt digital apps, stores, and platforms as selling methods, "old fashioned" brick-and-mortar sales are still alive and well.

By Hitha Herzog